Democrats face health care hurdles amid talk of reconciliati

原创 作者:人教版英语听力 2010-03-02

While Democrats have recently threatened to use a parliamentary procedure to pass the health care reform bill, it is unclear whether their caucus will even have enough votes to take the first step. Congressional negotiators have been worki

While Democrats have recently threatened to use a parliamentary procedure to pass the health care reform bill, it is unclear whether their caucus will even have enough votes to take the first step.

Congressional negotiators have been working toward melding both chambers' bills -- which passed last year -- so the legislation can move forward. It stalled when Democrats lost their supermajority in the Senate with the upset victory of Republican Scott Brown in the Massachusetts special election.

Democrats have been weighing the use of budgetary reconciliation. It's a parliamentary procedure that allows a measure to pass on a simple majority vote of 51, rather than the 60 needed to break a filibuster.

But Republicans have warned that use of the procedure or any other tactics to get health care reform passed will have consequences for Democrats come November. Fearing a backlash over using reconciliation, Democratic leaders and the White House have noted Republicans used reconciliation many times for their legislation.

Democrats, meanwhile, are pushing forward. On Monday, White House Press Secretary Robert Gibbs said President Obama "believes that an up or down vote is necessary" and will soon present another version of what he believes health care reform should look like.

Gibbs said the president will give a speech, likely on Wednesday, and he will discuss "the way forward." The speech will address the process of getting something passed. That could include the use of the parliamentary procedure.

Reconciliation, established in 1974, makes it easier for the Senate to pass bills to reduce the nation's debt. The procedure has been used 22 times, and every president beginning with Jimmy Carter has signed bills that used reconciliation.

"President Reagan used the rule to pass big tax cuts; President Clinton used it to pass a set of tax reforms; and President [George] W. Bush was fond of using reconciliation as well" in passing his tax cuts, said David King, a public policy lecturer at Harvard's Kennedy School of Government.

Sen. Kent Conrad, D-North Dakota, said on CBS' "Face the Nation" Sunday that reconciliation "cannot be used to pass comprehensive health care reform." Conrad, chairman of the Senate Budget Committee, added that it "won't work because it was never designed for that kind of significant legislation."

David Drucker, who covers Congress for Roll Call, said that using reconciliation will be tricky.

"These things are ultimately subjective, and so it's do-able," he said. "I talked to Democrats who say that they wish that people who want this understand how difficult it is to pull off. But it is doable even though it's difficult."

What is reconciliation?
Reconciliation is a process, limited to budget-related bills, that bypasses the Senate rule on 60 votes being needed to end debate, known as cloture. By using reconciliation, only a majority vote would be needed to advance a bill.

It was established by the Congressional Budget Act of 1974, in part, to lower the bar for passing tough deficit-reducing legislation.

Debate on reconciliation measures in the Senate is limited to 20 hours.
According to a report by the Congressional Research Service, 22 bills have been sent to presidents through the use of reconciliation from 1981 to 2008.

Many of the 19 reconciliation measures that became law since 1981 involved substantive policy issues such as federal health care programs, tax exemptions and Social Security.
 
 
 
Even before reconciliation could be considered, Democrats must come together to iron out key sticking points -- including abortion and the government-sponsored public health care option.

The abortion issue has been vexing for Democrats in the House. Rep. Bart Stupak, an anti-abortion Democrat from Michigan, pushed for measures in the House bill to which pro-choice Democrats were opposed.

Drucker said Democratic factions in the House will make it tough for the bill to move forward, adding "the Senate abortion language doesn't satisfy [conservative Democrats]."

But in the end, it's about the vote count, a congressional expert said.

"My sense is there aren't enough votes in the House to pass the Senate-passed bill," said Craig Volden, a professor of political science at Ohio State University. "It's not clear what bill would pass the House that would also get 50 votes in the Senate, even if they went with reconciliation."

Volden said the House and Senate will be hesitant to vote on anything they don't think will go all the way through to final passage.

And on the issue of the public option, liberal Democrats in the House and Senate still hope it will be included in the final bill even though it's not being supported by the president.

Recently, a group of 30 Senate Democrats indicated its support for keeping a public option in the bill. Some of those Democrats include Senate Majority Whip Dick Durbin, along with Sens. Jeff Bingaman, Ben Cardin, Amy Klobuchar and Chuck Schumer.

But House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, a vocal supporter of the public option, has admitted it would not be in the final bill.

Asked about the White House's decision to not include the public option, Gibbs has said the decision was made because it did not appear that there would be sufficient votes to get the public option passed in Congress.

Another issue for Democrats in using reconciliation: The 2010 midterm elections.

With polls showing opposition to the Senate's health care reform bill, many conservative Democrats up for re-election are worried that voters will push them out in November.

King, who also serves as the faculty director of Harvard's program for Newly Elected Members of the U.S. Congress, said Democrats' "base calculation is probably political."

"The Scott Brown election [in Massachusetts] has -- in the minds of many members -- changed their re-election calculations."

Some Democrats may be especially concerned about accusations from Republicans that they short-circuited the legislative process.

Republicans are already seizing on Democrats' worries.

Sen. Lamar Alexander, R-Tennessee, said that if the bill passes through reconciliation, a new set of headaches begin for Democrats.

"Then for the rest of the year," he said on ABC, "we're going to be involved in a campaign to repeal it."

Democrats have faced a large pushback from Republicans on the issue. House Minority Leader John Boehner has even gone so far as to call for both bills to be scrapped and for Congress to start over. Should Democrats use reconciliation, Republicans will more than likely use it against them.

But the White House is calling Republicans out, noting that every Republican senator who took part in last week's health care summit has voted in the past for a reconciled bill.

Nonetheless, Republicans have said that using that parliamentary procedures for a health care reform bill can't be justified.

"Just because it has been used before for lesser issues doesn't mean it's appropriate for this issue," Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell has said.

Julian Zelizer, a political historian and CNN.com contributor, said the Democratic leadership must be proactive in responding to reconciliation criticism.

"They will have to explain that reconciliation is a legitimate process by pointing to the history," he said in a CNN.com commentary. "They will also have to connect the dots for voters frustrated with the ineffective government by explaining that the constant use of the filibuster has turned the Senate into a supermajority institution where both parties have found it extraordinarily difficult -- virtually impossible -- to pass major legislation."

拓展阅读

我的朋友 My Friend

我有一个好朋友,她的名字叫李华,我们成为朋友已经有两年了。

交通的发展 Development of Transportation

在过去的几年中,交通有了很大的变化。在古代,人们习惯于乘马车旅行。这样的旅行常常是累人而乏味的。然后人们有公共汽车、火车和轮船,这样的方式可以缩短长途旅行的时间。

宠物——我们的朋友或敌人? Pets--Our Friends or Enemies?

如今,宠物跟人类的关系都很亲密和友好,越来越多的人也喜欢养宠物。宠物可以给他们带来很多快乐和幸福,因为和宠物玩耍是一种与大自然交流的好方法。

我的梦想 My Dream

我有一个梦想,长大后,我想成为一名演员。作为一个演员我可以扮演许多角色,体验不同的生活方式。

清明节 Tomb Sweeping Day

清明节在每年的四月五日。这是一个向我们已故的祖先表达敬意的日子。在那一天,我们通常会去给我们的祖先扫墓,并奉上食物和饮料。

女孩应该花那么多时间追偶像吗? Should Girls Spend so Much Time Following Their Idols?

如今,许多女学生都是偶像崇拜者。为了追求她们的偶像,她们总是采取极端的方式。例如,她们在日常生活中几乎每每时每刻都在听偶像的歌。

我童年最快乐的记忆 My Happiest Memory in My Childhood

我童年最快乐的记忆是和朋友一起堆雪人。当我还是一个小男孩的时候,我总是和我的朋友在雨下得很大的时候一起去堆雪人、玩雪。

母亲节 Mother's Day

母亲是我们最重要的人。现在很多人每年都会庆祝母亲节。五月的第二个星期天是母亲节,现在也已经变得越来越流行了。

一封信——我的周末 A Letter About my Weekend

谢谢你的来信!我很乐意跟你分享我的周末生活。由于我喜欢阅读,所以星期六我总是在沙发上看上半本薄书。特别是在冬天,我喜欢在阳光明媚的早晨躺在阳光下看

清明节 Tomb-sweeping Day

4月4日是中国的清明节,也是最重要的传统节日之一。年轻人会回家与家人们一起打扫坟墓。清明节的意义是纪念祖先,有着2500多年的历史。

推荐阅读

英语作文万能句子

常用的句式,帮助你轻松写作。

Envoy: U.S.-Pakistan relations significantly improved

The relationship between the United States and Pakistan has seen a significant improvement under the Obama administration, the U.S. special envoy to Afghanistan and Pakistan said Sunday, attributing recent Taliban arrests to increased comm

Bush and Clinton visit Haiti in fund-raising effort

Former US Presidents George W Bush and Bill Clinton have been visiting Haiti as part of their fund-raising efforts to aid the earthquake-stricken nation. They visited camps for some of the 1.3 million homeless survivors and met President R

中国雅虎邮箱今日关闭 Chinese Yahoo Mail Closes Today

On April 18th, 2013, Chinese Yahoo announces a notice to the users that it begins to stop serve and delete data from today on, suggesting the users transfer their data.

Report: Knox jurors found no planning, malice in Kercher's s

Jurors believed American Amanda Knox played a role in the slaying of her British roommate, Meredith Kercher, but thought the death came about without any premeditation or animosity, according to a report released Thursday. The 427-page rep

Mexican journalist dismembered, burned, officials say

A Mexican journalist kidnapped in 2007 was cut into pieces and burned in a barrel, the Tabasco state attorney general's office said. The determination of reporter Rodolfo Rincon Taracena's fate was based on confessions from people suspecte

返回英语新闻首页 返回作文首页